What Would Jane Austen Think of Our Modern-Day Customs?
Jane Austen, the sharp-witted observer of early 19th-century society, had an unrivaled ability to dissect human behavior with humor, irony, and a touch of gentle satire. Her novels, brimming with keen social commentary, continue to resonate centuries later. But what would the beloved author make of our modern customs? Would she delight in our progress, or would she raise a quizzical brow at our peculiar habits?
Let’s step into a world where Austen, in all her Regency refinement, takes a stroll through the 21st century.
Love & Courtship: "What Do You Mean, No Chaperone?"
For Austen, the art of courtship was a delicate dance of subtlety, restraint, and careful observation. A gentleman’s character was revealed through his letters, his reputation, and his behavior in polite society. Today’s fast-paced, often digital approach to romance would likely leave her stunned.
Dating Apps: The idea that one might "swipe right" to select a potential partner without so much as a formal introduction would be a horror worthy of a gothic novel. “What, no letters? No lingering glances across a ballroom? A gentleman’s character summed up in a single photograph?” she might exclaim.
Casual Dating: The modern tendency toward noncommittal relationships and casual encounters would be scandalous by Regency standards. The phrase "situationship" alone might send her into fits of laughter—or deep despair.
Public Displays of Affection: Holding hands in the street, let alone kissing in public, would be enough to make her clutch her pearls. In her world, even a touch of the hand could send shivers down one’s spine.
However, Austen might applaud the idea that women can now choose their partners freely, without worrying about financial necessity. Elizabeth Bennet would no longer have to fear becoming an old maid, and Charlotte Lucas might not have had to marry Mr. Collins purely for security.
Fashion: "Where Are Your Gloves?"
Austen’s era was one of elegance, where both men and women dressed with decorum, even in the privacy of their own homes. The sight of modern-day fashion—crop tops, ripped jeans, sneakers—might leave her speechless.
Athleisure & Casual Wear: The idea of people walking about in yoga pants and hoodies outside of their homes would be unfathomable. “Pray, are you in mourning? No? Then why are you clad in black from head to toe?”
Ball Gowns Replaced by Mini Dresses: The absence of empire waistlines and the shocking brevity of modern dresses would surely lead to a few gasps.
No Hats or Gloves: “Do people no longer respect the importance of accessories?” she might wonder. A Regency lady wouldn’t be caught dead outside without her bonnet, gloves, and reticule.
However, she might appreciate the comfort of modern clothing—corset-free living might earn a nod of approval.
Manners & Conversation: "Where Is Your Sense of Civility?"
Austen’s world revolved around the art of polite conversation, where wit and intelligence were prized, and letters were carefully penned with thoughtful precision. The abrupt nature of modern communication would likely horrify her.
Texting & Social Media: The loss of formal letter-writing would sadden her greatly. “One does not simply say ‘LOL’ instead of laughing!” she might cry. The idea that entire relationships can be conducted via emojis would be utterly baffling.
Ghosting & Ignoring Messages: In her day, leaving a letter unanswered was a grave insult. To simply “leave someone on read” would be the height of rudeness.
Oversharing Online: The modern tendency to share every detail of one’s life on social media might amuse and bewilder her in equal measure. “Why, pray, must one broadcast one’s breakfast to the entire world?”
Yet, she might admire the way people now freely express their opinions. No longer are young ladies expected to sit silently while men pontificate on politics and literature.
Women’s Independence: "Ah, Now This I Do Like"
Austen, despite living in a world that restricted women’s rights, created heroines who defied expectations. Elizabeth Bennet, Elinor Dashwood, and Anne Elliot all demonstrated intelligence, independence, and quiet rebellion.
Women in the Workplace: The sight of women running businesses, holding political office, and living independently would surely please her. She might even consider a career as an editor, critic, or novelist without the need for anonymity.
No Need to Marry for Security: The fact that women can now own property, earn their own income, and remain single without societal condemnation would be cause for celebration.
The Right to Vote: A triumph indeed! “If only I could have cast a ballot against the most insufferable of men,” she might muse.
Entertainment: "Where Are the Country Dances?"
Austen’s characters spent their evenings engaging in music, dancing, and lively conversation. The modern world's obsession with screens—television, video games, and endless scrolling—would likely baffle her.
Netflix Binges: The idea of watching hours of entertainment without ever rising to take a turn about the room would strike her as excessive.
Music & Dancing: Would she appreciate modern music? Perhaps. But one imagines her dismay at the decline of live piano performances in the drawing room.
Regency-Inspired Films & Shows: Austen might find herself delighted by the resurgence of Regency in pop culture. Bridgerton, Pride and Prejudice adaptations, and immersive experiences that celebrate her world would surely bring her great amusement.
Final Thoughts: Would Austen Approve of the Modern Age?
Ultimately, Jane Austen might find much to admire in the modern world—particularly the freedoms women now enjoy. However, she would likely long for the return of elegance, wit, and manners in everyday life.
Would she trade her candlelit drawing rooms and carefully composed letters for instant messaging and TikTok dances? Likely not. But if she were alive today, one thing is certain—her sharp observations of society would make for some truly scathing, and utterly brilliant, modern novels.
Perhaps, in the end, she would find herself writing not about Mr. Darcy, but about the strange customs of a world where love is found through swiping, conversation is reduced to GIFs, and bonnets are but a thing of the past.
What do you think? Would Jane Austen be charmed or appalled by modern society? Let us know in the comments!
Comments